We ran into our first problem when we entered his office. It was an old building, a somewhat faint reminder of Victorian Bangalore. The room itself must have been the size of my hall - There were bookshelves and drawers lining the walls, but the room itself was fairly empty. After about ten seconds, we managed to locate Dr. Aruni, sitting in a far corner of the room in a large armchair, in front of a broad oak desk.
First problem solved.
Now I had to move on the the impossible task of conversing with a stranger. It is impossible to explain how difficult this is for a person like me. The mind just shuts down, unwilling to give the body any instructions on how to proceed.
Luckily, I had my dad with me, whose ability to talk exceeds all expectations. While the two of them were busy talking about, well, whatever two humans are supposed to talk about (I'm quite inexperienced in this field), I was busy staring at all the interesting curios lined against the walls. When they finally moved from the common topics of well-being and weather and politics and whatnot, the conversation finally transitioned to archaeology and the work Dr. Aruni does. At last, something I could talk about.
We faced our second problem when he stood up to show us some Colonial British bottles. While he was sitting down in his chair, it was obvious that he was short, but standing up, we realized he was vertically impaired. Standing at a towering 4' 11", we had to try our best to conceal our shock. It was quite amusing, really.
Second problem solved.
Moving on.
Dr. Aruni showed us bottles that he had recovered from city constructions. Each of them was over 150 years old, and other than a few cracks and chips, they were in pristine condition. He began telling us about the struggle just to salvage a few artifacts amidst the metro construction, and the numerous conflicts he had with the Archaeological Survey of India. Apparently heaps of relics had been found near the metro, but the workers had just thrown them away, considering them garbage. He then proceeded to explain to us how us Indians love our sport, our food, our tradition, but we care nothing for our history.
He was absolutely right.
We take immense pride in traditional indian food, our love for cricket, and our innumerable festivals, yet etched into our monuments are the names of people who find some everlasting joy in desecrating ancient buildings.
Let's look at America for example. A country with a microscopic history in comparison to other civilizations. Yet somehow every American student has memorized the founding fathers of their country, knows the complete biography of Honest Abe, and can recite Martin Luther King Jr.'s "I have a dream" speech. And why? Because they love their country.
I ask people here about Tipu Sultan, and most of the time I get a "huh?". Nobody knows who the great Asoka was and the only reason people have heard about Akbar is because of picture stories about his famous adviser, Birbal.
Problem number three.
For a country with a history so vast and intricate, it's quite depressing that the subject is almost neglected in schools. It's always math, physics, chemistry, or business that receives importance. History should be given the same value as all these other subjects, if not more. After all, history is what starts a country. It is why we celebrate Diwali with lamps and fireworks. It is why Indian food is so flavorful and rich. It is why India vs Pakistan cricket matches are always the best.
Mainly, it is why Indians have stood together for so many years.
When a country gives no regard to its past, its future is doomed. That's why the future of India lies in the past. Awareness of artifact destruction must be raised, and monuments have to be protected. Holidays aren't just restricted to island paradises and a continental tour of Europe - some of the best places are right here, in India. These attractions need popularity, and quickly. Otherwise, they will silently crumble, along with our country.
Third problem - unsolved.
Good observations Dushyant.
ReplyDeleteThough slightly harsh on poor Dr Aruni - it's funny how a single word 'towering' can twist sensibility :)
Regarding India's famous neglect for historical places - it's about time next generation put some concrete ideas in place. I am sure if you ask around you will find dozens of good ideas on how to fix this problem. Argumentative Indians are never short of ideas.
I believe people of your age are in a strong position to fix these behavioral problems. Start with Facebook Page, or Wikipedia or Youtube channel, start a music band or go on a RTI spree but bring some fresh perspective. Problem is clear - Indians don't respect archaeological sites and have no shared pride in their monuments and artifacts.
I hope in next blog posts you will outline some possible shots at solving this problem.
Good blog post! Keep it up.
You are sounding too much angry young man and also holy young man - you are right and every Indian who doesnt articulate history is an idiot.
ReplyDeleteI think you got to get off the pedastal and enjoy history and just tell the story - you do have a good style and sense of story telling so I do think people will like reading what you write.
Look at it this way - if history was really popular everyone knew what you are writing about, it would be boring and nothing novel right:)?
So write on - from ground level view or from 30000 feet. just the pedastal doesnt suit you.
Cheers, look forward to next pow wow, and its good that you actually are giving up a bit of your shyness and making people like me too to get involved. And as a bonus I got in touch with my friend Tipu.
..Like the way you have written the piece. Tipu "huh?"... I think you should be prepared for these kind of reactions from our folks and also a very indifferent attitude towards History as a subject.
ReplyDeleteHaving said this, I think you can make a difference by creating interest in History around you with a slight different treatment to your article. It should be a good balance between keeping the subject matter strong and yet make it light to read.
Srini
Hey, beautifully written!!! I have heard you describe your meeting with Aruni...readin it was way better!!!:-)
ReplyDeleteYour understanding of the problems, in all your blogs have been spot on...so get out of just writing and go out there and start something that will change the way of things.
AND I KNOU YOU ARE NOT TOO SHY TO TAKE THIS ON!!! WAY TO GO IS FORWARD WITH A FOCUS ON THE HISTORY - THE FUTURE DOES INDEED LIE IN THE PAST!!!
Vow, quite a lot of material to dig and digest! Pretty interesting stuff. It took sometime to go through. Interesting to note your continued interest in this subject for a very long time!
ReplyDeleteNice post.
ReplyDeleteI wonder if a disinterest in the past is a common trait of countries with a recent colonial history. Is the desire to move on stronger than the desire to remember where "we" came from when the past brings up painful memories?
The US history examples you used are all about positive things (Honest Abe) not about the negative (Native American boarding schools). Selective memory is a human universal. Maybe the past you want India to remember is one they have chosen to forget?
I would like to believe that, but the fact that "Bombay", "Calcutta", and "Madras" are used more frequently than their original counterparts (at least in my interactions) makes me believe that we aren't trying to forget that section of our past. Additionally, many of the roads in the older parts of the bigger cities are still British names, and haven't been changed in the 66 years since our independence.
ReplyDeleteUnder Mussolini's rule, Italy glorified the golden age of Rome and the grandeur of its monuments, in order to boost the confidence of its people and to intimidate other countries by displaying a powerful visage. As sleazy as it may sound, I wish India could do the same. Looking at the way the rupee is going at the moment, we really could do with some income in the tourism sector.
Just some thoughts I had.
Is the non-colonial past taught in school with any detail? Maybe people are disinterested because they do not know why they should be interested.
ReplyDelete